The rolling returns every month for Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) across three major indices—Nifty 100 TRI (Large Cap), Nifty Midcap 150 TRI (Mid Cap), and Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI (Small Cap)—over various time horizons (3 to 15 years) from April 2005 to March 2025. This analysis evaluates the maximum, minimum, average, and median returns, along with the frequency of positive returns and returns exceeding certain thresholds (8%, 10%, and 12%), to provide insights into the risk-return profiles of these market segments.
- Large Cap (Nifty 100 TRI): The average return
ranges from 10.3% (3 years) to 12.3% (15 years), with a median return
stabilizing around 13.0%-13.2% over longer periods. Maximum returns peak
at 26.6% (3 years), while minimum returns dip to -36.8% (3 years),
indicating higher short-term volatility.
- Mid Cap (Nifty Midcap 150 TRI): The average return
increases from 13.9% (3 years) to 16.9% (15 years), with a median return
ranging from 18.6% (3 years) to 17.2% (15 years). Maximum returns reach
37.5% (3 years), but minimum returns are significantly negative at -63.0%
(3 years), reflecting higher volatility.
- Small Cap (Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI): The average return ranges from 11.9% (3 years) to 14.1% (15 years), with a median return peaking at 17.8% (5 years) and stabilizing around 14.4% (15 years). Maximum returns hit 42.1% (3 years), but minimum returns drop to -64.7% (3 years), indicating the highest short-term risk.
Returns Exceeding Thresholds
- 8% Return: Large Cap achieves this 68%-98% of the
time, Mid Cap 68%-100%, and Small Cap 66%-92%, with higher consistency
over longer periods.
- 10% Return: Large Cap ranges from 57%-93%, Mid Cap
from 66%-98%, and Small Cap from 61%-87%, with Small Cap showing a notable
drop in shorter periods.
- 12% Return: Large Cap ranges from 44%-83%, Mid Cap from 64%-92%, and Small Cap from 59%-82%, with Mid and Small Caps outperforming Large Caps in frequency over longer horizons.
- Small Caps offer the highest maximum returns (42.1%
over 3 years) but also the deepest losses (-64.7% over 3 years),
suggesting the highest risk-reward potential.
- Mid Caps strike a balance with solid average
returns (up to 16.9%) and moderate volatility compared to Small Caps.
- Large Caps provide the most stability, with lower
maximum returns (26.6%) and less severe minimum losses (-36.8%), making
them suitable for conservative investors.
Takeaways for SIP Investors:
- For stability: Large Caps offer a high probability
of positive returns (91%-100%) and a median return of 10.9%-13.5%.
- For better growth: Mid Caps outperform large caps
in long-term returns while maintaining relatively high positive return
probabilities.
- For high risk-high reward: Small Caps show huge
upside potential but come with significant short-term risks, requiring
patience and a long-term approach.
Ultimately, a diversified approach, allocating investments across Large, Mid, and Small-cap funds based on risk tolerance and investment horizon, is the best strategy for maximizing returns while managing risk effectively.