Does this mean the IT sector will struggle for long, and one will not get the historical returns, also? When we further investigated and found a huge long-term gap which impact the long-term returns too. One needs to revisit the thematic funds allocation.
One must understand the various angles of the IT industry problems created over the past 10 years, and there is no immediate relief or solution. The Indian IT sector is an old-age home. Mr Murthy might criticise people asking to work 70 hours but not investing enough in R&D. The biggest problem with the IT industry, which is like a disease, is that they have a sales mindset and not an R&D mindset, which creates more problems to adapt to the culture of R&D in IT. Supply of cheap labour and aggressive buyout of companies to uplift the shareholders' value and market capitalisation of shares is no longer going to survive in the Indian IT industry. Get ready for more correction in in the Indian IT sector since the culture of R&D will take time to get adopted and reflected in numbers on the P&L and balance sheet.
The Indian IT industry has historically allocated a low
percentage of revenue to research and development (R&D), typically ranging
from 0.5% to 1.2% across major firms. This is significantly below global
averages for tech sectors, where peers in the US, China, and other countries
invest 29-55% of profits in R&D. The industry as a whole has focused more
on operational efficiency and shareholder returns rather than innovation-led
growth.
Annual R&D Spending (Recent Years)
·
TCS: ~₹2,751 crore (1.1% of revenue) in FY24,
consistent at 1.0-1.2% since FY15.
·
Infosys: ~₹655 crore (0.5% of revenue) in FY23, stable
at 0.5% since FY17 (down from 1.3% in FY15).
·
HCL Tech: ~₹552 crore (1.1-1.3% of revenue) in
FY23, up from 0.6-1.0% pre-FY20
·
Wipro and Tech Mahindra: Similar patterns, with
R&D at 0.5-1.0% of revenue, estimating ~₹500-600 crore each annually based
on comparable peers.
The broader IT/software sector (including mid-tier firms),
annual R&D was ₹1,500-1,600 crore in recent years, suggesting a 10-year
total of ~₹15,000-20,000 crore, though this may undercount expensed R&D not
always reported as a separate line item.
Now, how much profits they earn, and what is the
contribution to R&D, shareholders wealth and executives perks? The top 5 IT firms generated ₹8.9 trillion in
cash profits since FY16 but reinvested only 13.5% (~₹1.2 trillion) in
growth/expansion (including some R&D), highlighting a preference for other
uses of capital.
The buybacks are the biggest use of profits, where the company
utilises its funds rather than investing in R&D.
For the top 5 IT firms, cumulative buybacks exceed ₹200,000 crore. Including mid-tier firms (e.g., Persistent Systems, L&T Infotech), the industry total is likely ₹220,000-250,000 crore. In 2023 alone, IT-heavy buybacks contributed to ~₹48,000 crore across 48 companies, with TCS spending ₹17,000 crore.
Over the decade, ~73% of cash profits from top IT firms
(₹6.46 trillion out of ₹8.9 trillion) went to dividends and buybacks. For the last 5 years (FY21-FY25), buybacks by
top IT firms totalled ~₹120,000-150,000 crore, driven by post-pandemic cash
surpluses.
So when you don’t have an AI agent of your own, you are
bound to lose jobs and lose investment value in the Indian IT industry. Now the
funny part will be that these giants will ask the government for freebies for
setting up R&D.
Now the final chunk of profits went to the back of C-suit
salaries. Top executive (CEO and C-suite) compensation in Indian IT has surged
significantly, outpacing general employee wage growth amid strong
profitability. Over the last 5 years, CEO pay at top IT firms rose by ~160%, while
fresher salaries increased only by ~4%.
In the past decade, average CEO pay across listed firms doubled to ~₹7.2 crore (9% CAGR), but IT executives earn far higher, often in the ₹50-150 crore range due to performance bonuses, stock options, and variable pay (60% of total).
The investment is so low that this sector will struggle for a
long time. Even some buyouts of IT platforms will not be of any help for the sector. It's time for financial advisors to relook into various sectors and realign the funds accordingly and investments. Those who are thinking that the current fall is an opportunity to buy well, the cheap is yet to become cheaper and the cheapest. Hence, wait and watch.
















.png)
